Sunday, October 08, 2006

Monkey

X-Sender: hcb8@bonjour.cc.columbia.edu
Subject: Re: ARFICANS and GORRILAS
In-Reply-To:
Message-ID:
References:
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII
Status: O
X-Status:

On 1 Dec 1994, Andrew Cooper wrote:

>
>
>
>
> In article person@postoffice.sandybay.utas.edu.au (Student@law.utas.edu.au) writes:
>
> From: person@postoffice.sandybay.utas.edu.au (Student@law.utas.edu.au)
>
> Some of the Africans I met look very alike gorrilas. I am not trying to
> offend but a sincere observation. Perhaps Charles Darwin was a little bit
> right.
>
> Nasreen
>
>
> You most certainly did offend. Perhaps you're a little bit ignorant, that
> is the only reason someone could come up with such a statement and think
> that it would be inoffensive. This message of yours implies that you think
> that "ARFICANS" are somewhat closer to "GORRILAS" than other people,
> implying that they are somehow lower down on the chain of evolution than
> others. How could you possibly, in any twisted or stunted way, think that
> this kind of utter crap would not offend? Is it true about what they say
> about people who are called "Nasreen" look like monkeys? :-)
>
>

First I would like to say that since Nasreen put her message here with no
preamble or explanation it did look to me very inflammatory. I want to
reply to both her message and this reply (above).

First of all I (an Black West African) also believe that I look more like
a gorrila than, say a white Iranian or a white African or a Black
North African or a white Swede -- in general. Lets face it, we ALL look
like gorrilas for the simple reason that they are our relatives. So are
rats, foxes, dear kangaroos etc etc. Now this has been recognised in
Africa for a long time and we make no big deal out of treating all Gods
creatures as our relatives and worthy of equal space and respect on the
planet. The problem is that both Nasreen and you subscribe to the
Darwinian idea that we are somehow superior to gorillas etc. so
obviously, she knew some other Darwinian out here would be offended and
you obliged! I am actually proud that I look and share some of the
behaviour of gorillas because if you watch some of the excellent nature
documentaries about gorillas you will find that they are gentle civilized
creatures that avoid the kinds of conflicts that some of us humans get
into. What Nasreen says is only offensive if you look down on gorillas
and I do not.

Since gorrilas have survived on this planet as long as we have and
overcome the same obstacle of day to day life. Since they bring up their
children with love and share with their neighbours they are as
intelligent as the next animal (including humans). Darwin formulated his
ideas at a time when White europeans (who definitely did not look or
BEHAVE in the same civilised manner as gorrilas) were busy trying to
justify enslaving thousands of Black Africans. Not surprisingly, there
is a certain hierarchical prejudice built into the formulation and all
the subsequent interpretations of his ideas that people now take as
"rational science". We need to stop "reacting" to racial slurs and
stereotypes -- that is the best way to make them powerless.

Coz "gorrilla mouth" Blyden
erb

No comments: